Thursday, November 6, 2025 -Ryan Murphy’s latest legal drama All’s Fair is off to a rough start as critics take aim at Kim Kardashian’s performance, calling it “flat,” “forced,” and “miscast.” The series, which premiered this week with Kardashian in a leading role as a high-powered Los Angeles divorce attorney, had been one of the year’s most anticipated television events.
Despite Murphy’s reputation for crafting stylish, character-driven stories, early reviews say the show fails to deliver the emotional depth audiences expected with much of the blame falling squarely on its star.
Public reaction has been just as polarized as Kardashian’s fame itself. Fans of the reality mogul rushed to defend her, praising her ambition and pointing out that her screen presence draws attention if not acclaim.
Critics, however, argue that Murphy’s gamble on celebrity casting overshadowed what could have been a compelling ensemble drama. Social media has been buzzing with memes and mixed reactions, with viewers joking that “the courtroom had more emotion than the cast.” Entertainment journalists note that while Kardashian brings undeniable star power, acting credibility remains elusive.
The backlash could mark a turning point for both Murphy and Kardashian. If ratings fail to recover, it may challenge Murphy’s reputation for balancing risk and spectacle, while Kardashian’s Hollywood aspirations could face renewed skepticism.
Yet industry insiders say it’s too early to count her out; controversy has always been part of her brand. Whether All’s Fair flops or finds its audience, it proves one thing: Kim Kardashian can still command the world’s attention, even when the verdict isn’t in her favor.
0 Comments